We'll create fresh WordPress site with Anonymous Restricted Content installed. You have 20 minutes to test the plugin after that site we'll be deleted.
This plugin is as simple as you expected!
And it support latest WordPress Gutenberg editor now!
Mark the content you want to hide as restricted with just a checkbox – and it’s done!
In case anonymous user will try to get access to restricted page or post – it will be redirected to WordPress Login page first.
Or you can specify the exact URL (internal or external) to redirect anonymous users to.
After successful authorization, user is redirected back to the requested page.
Also, it hides restricted posts from Archive and Categories pages, RSS feed and from Latest Comments/Posts widgets!